The decision requires plan proponents to identify retained causes of action with specificity at confirmation, demonstrate their material connection to the debtor's financial distress or plan success, and show that retention is genuinely necessary—thereby moving jurisdictional disputes to the front end of the case rather than leaving them for costly post-confirmation litigation.
Litigation claims are in some instances the most valuable assets left in a liquidating Chapter 11 case. But often, an obscure question lingers: does the bankruptcy court still have the jurisdiction to adjudicate a post-confirmation lawsuit? In the case of In re Simply Interior Homes, No. 26-10922 (CTG) (Bankr. D. Del. Sept. 22, 2026), Judge Craig Goldblatt of the U.S. Bankruptcy Court for the District of Delaware (the court) offered a practical answer and provided practitioners with a roadmap for how a liquidating trustee can have those claims adjudicated in the bankruptcy court after confirmation.
Background and Procedural Posture
The debtors, a home textiles and décor business, were “carved out” of a predecessor company in a transaction that allegedly left them undercapitalized from day one, with “no cash” and burdensome debt. As a result, the debtors filed for bankruptcy in June 2026.
Following the commencement of the bankruptcy cases, the debtors, the creditors’ committee, and the secured lenders resolved their issues and developed and promulgated the terms of a liquidating plan. Rather than keep operating, the business would wind down, and a post-confirmation “liquidating trust” would pursue the debtors’ claims against their predecessor and their private equity sponsor.
As noted by the court, there is a legal wrinkle: namely, when a plan takes effect, the bankruptcy estate normally dissolves and its property vests in a new entity. As such, there theoretically is no “related to” jurisdiction as there is no estate that these claims could relate to or impact. Simply put, if the estate no longer exists, how can a claim affect it? In its decision, the court noted that the U.S. Court of Appeals for the Third Circuit in Resorts International addressed this issue by requiring a “close nexus” between the claim and the confirmed plan, a standard that the court candidly described as producing “messy” results. As the court warned, quoting its own earlier decision, such rules can operate “as a form of Rorschach test,” with jurisdiction found “if the ink blot looks like a moth but not if it looks more like a rabbit.”
The Decision
Building on its earlier 2026 decisions in SunPower and Cyber Litigation, the court relied on Section 1141(b) of the Bankruptcy Code, which permits a plan to retain specified property in the estate rather than “revesting” it elsewhere. If a claim remains estate property, its “monetization” directly affects an estate that still exists, satisfying the ordinary related-to test.
As noted by the court, this is not a loophole. Rather, as the court stressed, keeping the estate open is the exception, not the rule. Nevertheless, the court held that under certain circumstances an “estate” could theoretically be left open for retained causes of action to be pursued if the following factors were met: the claims are identified with specificity; they bear a material connection to the debtor’s financial distress, the plan’s success, or expected creditor recoveries; retention is genuinely necessary to carry out the plan, not just a way to pick a favored court; and the plan limits the exception to those identified claims.
In the Simply Interior Homes case, the debtors met this test. The debtors named the specific claims and defendants in their plan supplement and backed the retention with sworn declarations. In addition, these specified claims were claims against the entities blamed for the debtors’ collapse and were central to any creditor recovery. The court did require the debtors to narrow their proposed confirmation order, which initially swept in claims beyond those specified in the plan supplement. With that fix, the court confirmed the plan. Importantly, the ruling decided only jurisdiction. It said nothing about whether the underlying claims would succeed, and all parties’ rights on the merits remain reserved.
Why It Matters
This decision is very important as it removes the “ink blot” from the post-confirmation jurisdiction analysis by moving the jurisdictional fight to the front end of the case. In so doing, the court noted that leaving these questions open invites wasteful fights—parties spending time and money litigating where a case belongs instead of who should win.
For practitioners, the guidance is concrete. Plan proponents should identify retained causes of action precisely, support them with a real evidentiary record at confirmation, and draft confirmation orders that neither overreach nor leave jurisdiction ambiguous. Where no claim needs to stay in the estate, the order should say the court will not exercise post-confirmation jurisdiction. Because jurisdiction is the court’s own responsibility, counsel should not assume an unopposed provision will be rubber-stamped; a specific factual showing, on proper notice, will be required.
Lawrence J. Kotler is a partner and co-chair of the bankruptcy and fiduciary representations division of the business reorganization and financial restructuring practice group at Duane Morris.
Drew S. McGehrin, an associate at the firm, practices in the areas of commercial finance, financial restructuring and bankruptcy.
Reprinted with permission from The Legal Intelligencer, © ALM Media Properties LLC. All rights reserved.


